5 Peer Editing Strategies That Actually Work For Student Writers

Peer editing is a valuable tool for students to improve their writing skills. By receiving feedback from their peers, students can gain new perspectives and identify areas for improvement in their own work. However, not all peer editing strategies are equally effective. In this article, we will explore five peer editing strategies that have proven to be successful for student writers.

  1. Guided Questioning: This strategy involves the editor asking specific questions about the writer’s work to stimulate critical thinking. By guiding the discussion with targeted questions, the editor helps the writer identify areas that may need improvement and encourages deeper analysis of their writing.
  2. Highlighting Strengths and Weaknesses: In this strategy, the editor focuses on both the strengths and weaknesses of the writer’s work. By pointing out what the writer is doing well, they can build confidence and reinforce effective writing techniques. At the same time, identifying weaknesses allows the writer to address areas for improvement.
  3. Peer Modeling: This strategy involves the editor providing an exemplary piece of writing that demonstrates a specific skill or concept the writer is struggling with. By seeing a successful example, the writer can better understand how to incorporate the skill or concept into their own work.
  4. Two Stars and a Wish: In this strategy, the editor identifies two positive aspects of the writer’s work (“stars”) and one area for improvement (“wish”). This approach provides balanced feedback and allows the writer to focus on both their strengths and areas that need further development.
  5. Rotating Roles: This strategy involves rotating the roles of writer and editor among the students. By taking turns in these roles, students can develop a better understanding of the writing process from different perspectives. This promotes collaboration, empathy, and a deeper appreciation for the editing process.

These five peer editing strategies have proven to be effective in helping student writers improve their skills. By implementing these strategies in the classroom, educators can create an environment that fosters growth, collaboration, and the development of critical thinking skills. Peer editing, when done right, can be a powerful tool for student writers to enhance their writing abilities and become more confident in their work.